Instead of arguing I want to envision other possible uses of the SITLA land currently in line to be turned into a hole in the ground.
New pit in paradise |
Oddly, there is another ongoing pit being dug in sight of my home. I understand it is on private land so perhaps there is nothing that could have been done to prevent this scar. To the Old West mindset the land is only a resource to be dug up, mined, logged, drained or grazed. If it can't be used up, it is not a resource. In this case, a private land owner was offered a lease to mine and accepted the offer in order to make some income from the land. Sadly, they have also ruined their land and undoubtedly badly damaged their personal balance sheet. That is the way of unsustainable extraction. A little income today in turn for the long term liability of hole in the ground, mine tailings and ruined land left for future generations to suffer.
The SITLA land could go another direction. Across the West, gateway towns to national parks are prospering. They are experiencing the best sustainable economic performance of any rural area. The areas committed to the boom and bust cycles of extraction industry lag further and further behind. Torrey Teasdale is at the juncture where it could become a model gateway community or decide, for some misguided sense of custom, to dig itself up.
Future gravel pit? |
An economically arrangement with urban downstream users to lease the water rights, and save a little to use for homes on the SITLA land would be a vast improvement. There is plenty of water. Just don't pour it on hay. The water would need to be treated, but a wise land developer could arrange for the treatment of enough water for 20 or 30 homes easily, efficiently, economically. There is plenty of water. All that is lacking is the vision and will. The farmer would benefit, SITLA would come out ahead, the county would come out hugely ahead, the valley's natural integrity and beauty would be sustained, the home owners would be lucky to have such a location.
I would be happiest to move into a place like Torrey and close the gate behind me to any more development. An unjustifiably entitled position, to be sure, but a typical one. Now I see that my closing the gate is going to leave the land unprotected. Better to plan and develop the are with people who are there for the natural beauty.
In upcoming posts I want to talk about local town annexation, about the Wayne County airport (38U), and dark skies. I want to envision what this exceptional gateway community could be.